# Ecommerce Due Diligence: What QoE and Commercial Diligence Miss

Source: https://trymimetic.com/guides/ecommerce-due-diligence

[Guides](/guides) / Revenue QA

# Ecommerce due diligence: what QoE and commercial diligence miss

Most deals get a quality of earnings report and a commercial diligence report. For an ecommerce brand, that leaves a gap: the storefront, the checkout and the tracking that produce the revenue. This guide covers that gap. It leans on the people who have studied diligence most closely and on the brokers who sell the most online businesses, and it credits each idea to its source.

## Why diligence keeps missing

The best evidence that standard diligence leaves money on the table comes from Bain & Company's private equity practice. Looking back at deals, Bain found that **"most of them (71% of investments) fell short of projected margins,"** and not by a little: **"on average, margins ended up 330 basis points below the deal model forecast."** Their diagnosis: diligence is usually **"siloed, which limits the buyer's understanding of how each aspect of the business relates to the others."**
*Source: Bain & Company, [Integrating Due Diligence to Build Lasting Value](https://www.bain.com/insights/integrating-due-diligence-to-build-lasting-value/) (2019).*

For an online brand, the part most often left out of the single inquiry Bain recommends is the website itself.

## The three lenses

It helps to separate the questions each kind of diligence answers.

- **Quality of earnings:** are the earnings real? Howard Schilit, author of *Financial Shenanigans*, says the questions to ask about any change in accounting or in what management highlights are **"Why?" and "Why now?"** ([CFA Institute interview](https://rpc.cfainstitute.org/blogs/enterprising-investor/2014/the-sherlock-holmes-of-accounting-howard-schilit-explains-what-he-does-and-how-does-it), 2014).
- **Commercial:** in Bain's words, it **"provides a perspective on how fast the target company's market will grow."**
- **Operational:** it **"assesses the opportunity for the target to expand margins,"** and gives the buyer **"a head start on pursuing savings immediately after the deal closes."**
  *Source: Bain & Company, [New Prominence for Operational Due Diligence](https://bain.com/insights/new-prominence-for-operational-due-diligence-in-pe-forbes) (2017).*

For an ecommerce brand, operational diligence has to include digital: does the site work, and can the numbers it reports be trusted.

## Tech diligence on a "non-tech" company

Bain's 2022 report found that while **"31% of all buyouts last year involved technology companies,"** only a small share of buyers diligence technology, and **"for buyouts generally, the rate is closer to 9%."** Their rule: **"Strong tech diligence has to be tied to the deal thesis from the outset."**
*Source: Bain & Company, [Tech Due Diligence](https://www.bain.com/insights/tech-due-diligence-global-private-equity-report-2022/) (Global Private Equity Report 2022).*

A DTC brand is filed as consumer, not tech, so it rarely gets this. Yet its storefront, checkout and analytics stack are its revenue engine. A tech workstream for a brand doesn't need an architecture review. It needs answers to four questions:

1. Does checkout work on the phones and browsers customers actually use, including the in-app browsers of Instagram and TikTok?
2. Are price, shipping and the buy button visible on a phone without scrolling?
3. Does the tracking count each order once, and do tags respect the shopper's cookie choice? (The legal side of consent is a question for counsel.)
4. What breaks if an app is removed, and who knows?

## Verify every number at its source

Empire Flippers, one of the largest online-business marketplaces, puts the rule plainly: **"Treat every figure in a listing as a claim until you have matched it to the source."** They ask buyers to get **"at least 12 months of Google Analytics and Google Search Console data, not tool estimates,"** and to **"check the manual actions report in Google Search Console. Never ignore a warning there."**
*Source: Empire Flippers, [Red flags when buying a business](https://empireflippers.com/buying-a-business-red-flags/).*

FE International adds that buyers **"should use Google Analytics to observe the trends in the overall traffic and for each channel."**
*Source: FE International, [Ecommerce business due diligence checklist](https://feinternational.com/blog/e-commerce-business-due-diligence-checklist) (2021).*

There's a step before that, which brokers rarely spell out: **check that the analytics themselves are right.** A theme tag and an app both sending purchases will double-count. A purchase tag that stopped firing reports zero, and zero looks like a bad month. Compare orders in the store platform with purchases in analytics, month by month. The two never match exactly, but the ratio should hold steady. A ratio that jumps is a tracking change, and every trend across that date is suspect.

## Is the marketing performance real?

This is where DTC diligence gets argued about, and where the experts disagree.

**Use contribution margin, not ROAS.** Common Thread Collective, the agency led by Taylor Holiday, defines it as **"Contribution Margin = (Net Sales + Shipping Revenue) - COGS - Ad Spend - Shipping & Fulfillment - Merchant Fees,"** and points out that **"ROAS doesn't account for COGS, shipping, or merchant fees."** Their summary: **"Revenue is vanity. Contribution margin is sanity."**
*Source: Common Thread Collective, [The complete guide to ecommerce contribution margin](https://commonthreadco.com/blogs/coachs-corner/the-complete-guide-to-ecommerce-contribution-margin) (2026).*

**Don't trust platform-reported results on their own.** Haus, which runs incrementality experiments for brands, analyzed **"640 Meta experiments"** and found that **"platforms are grading their own homework."** The twist is that in their sample Meta's attribution *under*-counted: for every $100 of platform-attributed revenue, **"Meta actually generated $115 in incremental revenue."** So the risk runs both ways.
*Source: Haus, [Is Meta incremental?](https://www.haus.io/blog/is-meta-incremental) (2025).*

**The dissent.** Andrew Faris, former CEO of an ecommerce aggregator, argues that **"there's no reason a brand under $50 million in revenue needs an attribution tool,"** and that the thing to do is **"closely monitor what happens after someone clicks."**
*Source: [Practical Ecommerce interview](https://www.practicalecommerce.com/ecom-exec-marketing-attribution-is-a-waste) (2023).*

The three agree on more than it seems. Holiday says **"the end result on the PNL is still the thing that governs truth"** ([Common Thread](https://commonthreadco.com/blogs/ecommerce-playbook/unpacking-incrementality), 2024). For a buyer, that means: reconcile marketing claims to the P&L, test incrementality where the spend is large, and look hard at what happens on the site after the click.

## Accounts, apps and access

Empire Flippers' ecommerce guide has the two instructions that matter most:

- **"Review the health of every ad, merchant and marketplace account, and confirm that each one can be transferred to you."**
- **"List every app, theme and software subscription the store pays for, and who has admin access to each."**

*Source: Empire Flippers, [Buying an ecommerce business](https://empireflippers.com/buying-an-ecommerce-business/).*

Add the domain registrar, which is the asset everything else depends on, and the analytics and Search Console properties, which are often owned by an agency rather than the business. An ad account that can't transfer means starting over without its history or its conversion setup.

## Red flags

- **"Things are almost always cheap for a reason, with some obvious defect or risk."** Brent Beshore of Permanent Equity, who also warns about **"the difference between EBITDA and earnings and cash flow"** ([2022 letter](http://www.permanentequity.com/content/15-years-in-the-trenches-of-smb-acquisitions-and-operations-2022-annual-letter)).
- **Owner dependence.** If the business only runs with the seller, [Empire Flippers](https://empireflippers.com/buying-a-business-red-flags/) calls it **"an unsustainable business because once you take the owner out of the equation, the business can't run."**
- **Concentration.** **"If most sales come from one marketplace, ad account or social channel, check its policy history and the account's health"** (Empire Flippers).
- **Changed definitions.** Schilit's "Why now?" applies to dashboards too. A seller who switched how conversions or customers are counted shortly before the sale owes an explanation.
- **Numbers only in screenshots.** If the seller can't give read access to the store, analytics and ad accounts, the marketing numbers can't be verified.

## From diligence to the 100-day plan

Bain's 2026 Global Private Equity Report argues for **"full potential due diligence,"** a single effort that both builds the deal case and sets up what happens after close ([Bain, 2026](https://www.bain.com/insights/welcome-to-a-new-era-global-private-equity-report-2026/)). Whatever the site checks turn up becomes the first page of the plan: broken checkout paths are the quickest wins, and a tracking baseline is what lets the new owner tell a real decline from a measurement change. The next step is the [post-acquisition integration checklist](/guides/post-acquisition-integration-ecommerce).

## How Mimetic helps

Mimetic checks a site the way shoppers use it, on phones and desktop and across browsers, and finds what's broken or leaking: checkout and add-to-cart problems, tracking that double-counts or drops purchases, tags that ignore consent, slow pages. Deal teams use it to see what a target's site actually does before close. With the brand's analytics connected, each problem comes with what it's likely costing.

## Common questions

**What is ecommerce due diligence?**
It's the review of an online business's website, analytics, ad accounts, apps and customer data, alongside the financial and legal work. It confirms that the reported revenue is real, that you'll own what produces it, and that it will keep working after the handover.

**What is the difference between commercial and operational due diligence?**
Commercial diligence asks how fast the market will grow and whether the target can win in it. Operational diligence asks whether the target can expand margins and what needs fixing. For an ecommerce brand, operational diligence should include the website and tracking.

**What is technology due diligence for a DTC brand?**
For most DTC brands it isn't a code review. It's checking that checkout works on the devices customers use, that tracking counts each order once, that the accounts transfer, and that someone besides the seller understands how the store is put together.

**How do you verify an ecommerce business's traffic and revenue?**
Get read access to the store platform, Google Analytics, Search Console and the ad accounts, ideally for 12 months or more. Match revenue to the store's orders and bank deposits, check that analytics counts orders correctly, and break traffic and revenue down by channel.

**What are red flags when buying an ecommerce business?**
A price that seems too good, owner dependence, most sales from one channel or account, changed metric definitions shortly before the sale, and numbers the seller can only show as screenshots.

Written by Coleman Hindes, founder, Mimetic.
Published 2026-11-22.

### See what a target's site does for shoppers before you close.

[Check a site](/)
